The Idaho Supreme Court on Friday refused to block a Republican-backed bill that would have banned abortion altogether, Reuters reported. In June, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the Constitution does not guarantee the right to terminate a pregnancy and that decisions are left to state officials, overturning the Supreme Court’s 1973 decision in Roe v. Wade, which recognized the constitutional right to abortion. .
Idaho state judges rejected the proposal by Planned Parenthood, which operates among others. Support wider access to legal contraception and abortion to prevent the ban from taking effect on August 25.
According to the organization, the law would violate the right to privacy and equal treatment, which are guaranteed in the Idaho state constitution.
In justifying the ruling, Justice Robin Brady wrote that Planned Parenthood had failed to prove it deserved such “draconian” relief, especially before the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, which recognized the constitutional right to surgical abortion. Illegal in Idaho.
“Furthermore, what the petitioners are asking for is a final declaration of the right to an abortion under the Idaho Constitution, which – in its view – has none,” Brady added.
Alexis McGill Johnson, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood of America, called the ruling “appalling and cruel.”
Reuters reminds us that almost half of US states are attempting or intend to ban or restrict abortion after the conservative majority decision of the US Supreme Court in June of this year. Among these states is Idaho, which, like 12 others, passed laws banning abortion after the decision.
Justice John Stegner, in a dissenting opinion, said the court should have acted more cautiously and blocked the ban in the meantime, arguing that “a fundamental right has never been taken away from citizens once in our nation’s history.”
The U.S. Justice Department filed a separate lawsuit Aug. 2 to block the ban in Idaho, saying it violates a federal law that requires hospitals to perform emergency abortions when needed.
The Aug. 22 lawsuit is the first federal action against the state’s abortion laws since the Supreme Court’s June ruling.
Five justices participated, rejecting Planned Parenthood’s motion by a score of three to two.
“Twitter’s irretrievable researcher. An amateur social media lawyer. Award-winning music expert. Became an addict. Easily lethargic.”